Charleston Design Review Board (DRB) Meeting Recap: March 3, 2025
The Charleston Design Review Board (DRB) convened on March 3, 2025, to review several significant projects that could shape the architectural and aesthetic character of the city. The meeting, chaired by Andy Smith, included board members Lucas Boyd, Ashley Jackrel, Aaron Stevens, and Stephanie Tillerson, with city staff members David Meeks and Brad Thomas in attendance. The agenda covered a range of requests, from partial demolitions to conceptual approvals for new constructions and renovations. Here’s a detailed recap of the key discussions and decisions made during the meeting.
1. Partial Demolition at 1460 Savannah Highway
The first item on the agenda was a request for partial demolition of windows, doors, and support columns at 1460 Savannah Highway, a building with a rich history dating back to 1946. Originally the Cavallaro Supper Club, the building has been a landmark in Charleston for decades. The applicant, Hendrick Automotive Group, represented by David E. of Redline Design Group, proposed replacing leaking windows and removing glass blocks on the sides of the building to improve functionality while preserving the building’s Art Deco character.
Key Points:
The building’s historical significance was highlighted, particularly its role during the big band era.
Staff recommended approval, emphasizing the importance of maintaining the building’s architectural integrity.
The board unanimously approved the partial demolition, noting that the changes were minor and did not compromise the building’s historic value.
2. Partial Demolition and Renovation at 1919 Maybank Highway
Next, the board reviewed a request for partial demolition and renovation of an existing office building at 1919 Maybank Highway. The project, led by Ashley Sherfield of Cobb Architects, involved removing windows, doors, porch stairs, and columns to convert the building into a market. The building, originally a farmhouse built around 1903, had undergone several additions over the years.
Key Points:
Staff supported the partial demolition, noting that the requested changes did not affect historically significant elements.
The board approved the demolition request, paving the way for the building’s transformation into a market.
Conceptual approval for the renovation was also granted, with staff recommendations to ensure operable shutters, proper landscaping, and alignment of windows to maintain the building’s aesthetic appeal.
3. Conceptual Approval for New Retail Buildings at West Ashley Circle
The final major item on the agenda was a request for conceptual approval for two new one-story retail buildings at West Ashley Circle. The project, presented by Blake Middleton of the Middleton Group, aimed to create a retail center with potential tenants including offices and restaurants. The design featured a mix of traditional brick materials and modern elements, with a focus on pedestrian-friendly spaces and outdoor dining areas.
Key Points:
Staff praised the design direction, particularly the use of varied materials and large window glazing.
Recommendations included revising one of the building designs to differentiate the two structures, adding entrances from West Ashley Circle, and enhancing landscaping.
The board granted conceptual approval, with additional suggestions to restudy the gable elevation materials and ensure proper screening for parking areas.
Public Engagement and Process
The meeting also highlighted the DRB’s commitment to public engagement. Instructions for submitting written comments and participating in public discussions were clearly outlined. While no public comments were submitted for the reviewed projects, the board ensured that all stakeholders had the opportunity to voice their opinions.
Approval of Previous Meeting Minutes
The board concluded the meeting by approving the minutes from the February 3, 2025, session, ensuring continuity and transparency in their decision-making process.
Final Thoughts
The March 3 DRB meeting showcased the delicate balance between preserving Charleston’s architectural heritage and accommodating modern needs. The board’s decisions reflected a thoughtful approach to development, ensuring that new projects enhance the city’s character while respecting its history. As these projects move forward, they promise to contribute to Charleston’s vibrant and evolving landscape.
Stay tuned for updates on these exciting developments as they progress through the design and construction phases!
Agenda #1 (Initial Presentation): https://www.charleston-sc.gov/AgendaCenter/ViewFile/Agenda/_03032025-9851
Agenda # 2 : https://www.charleston-sc.gov/AgendaCenter/ViewFile/Agenda/_03032025-9850
Agenda # 3 (Meeting Results) : https://www.charleston-sc.gov/AgendaCenter/ViewFile/Agenda/_03032025-9887
Meeting Video : https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KDR8248n_os
*meeting auto transcribed, please excuse any typos & misspellings
If you're looking to buy or sell a home in Charleston, Bill Olson & Pirate Properties can help you. We’re fast, friendly, knowledgeable, and fun to work with. We’ve helped hundreds of clients in real estate. Click below and start viewing what's available in Charleston today, calculate your home’s value, or schedule a no-obligation, no-pressure discovery call.
